TWD: Coconut Butter Thins

Tuesday, March 31, 2009


Working your way through an entire cookbook, recipe by recipe can be a tricky business. Especially, when someone else is choosing the recipes for you! Sometimes, you’re delighted by what you end up with – and sometimes, not. While Dorie’s Coconut Butter Thins do contain several ingredients that I love – butter, coconut, lime, macadamia nuts and ground coriander – I didn’t really love them in this cookie. Don’t get me wrong, I LIKED the cookies. I just didn’t LOVE them.

Coconut Butter Thins are supposed to be thin, crispy and lacy shortbread-like cookies. And mine were. But to me, the flavors were so subtle that they were virtually undetectable. I got no sunny pop of lime or scent of coriander. Nor did I find much crunch of macadamia nuts. I did get some chewiness from the coconut, but mostly in the annoying shreds that peeked out from my neatly cut cookie shapes. They were a nice little unassuming cookie that would probably be great paired with something else, but without much personality of their own.


I also think that there’s a reason that there is no accompanying photo of these cookies in the book. My cookies were just not very photogenic. When baked, they flattened out and spread a bit so that their edges blurred. I made one sheet of cookies cut into squares as Dorie directs in the recipe. Once out of the oven, they took on a kind of stretchy, Dali-esque quality. I cut the next batch into rounds which held their shape better, but not much. To be fair, I do think that I rolled my cookies a little too thin. I don’t know how much that affected the shape, if at all.

I’m sorry, Dorie! You know I love you. But, these just didn’t do it for me the way so many of your other fantastic recipes have.


Thanks to Jayne from The Barefoot Kitchen Witch for choosing our recipe for this week. If you’d like to see how the rest of the TWD gang fared with these Coconut Butter Thins, check out the Tuesdays with Dorie blogroll.

more of what\'s cooking...

Dinner and a Movie: Moonstruck Roundup (Pasta alla Norma)

Monday, March 30, 200937 Comments

Moonstruck is a delightful and endearing romantic comedy about love and life set in New York City’s Italian-American community. In it, Loretta Castorini, (brilliantly played by Cher), an unlucky in love Italian widow (her first husband was hit by a bus) finds romance through the intervention of la …

Daring Bakers, Italian-Style: Lasagne Verdi al Forno

Friday, March 27, 200965 Comments

Buon giorno, amici! It’s Daring Bakers time again, and this month my colleagues and I are channeling our inner Italian Nonnas. We’ve replaced our vanilla beans with spinach, our buttercream with béchamel and our ganache with ragu. We’ve made lasagne, and lots of it, from scratch – including …

See What See’s Has Hatched for Easter and Toffee-ette Tortoni

Thursday, March 26, 200945 Comments

Last December, in a mad dash to beat the Christmas Rush, I stumbled upon an interesting new kiosk in one of our local malls. The kiosk was filled products from a company called See’s Candies.
See’s Candies???
Ahem……It goes without saying that I had to …

Rest in Peace, Sweet Maria

Monday, March 23, 200964 Comments

Oh Dear Readers, you have no idea how much I hate writing posts like this. Yet, I find myself doing it way too often. My heart is heavy today and it probably will be for a long time. And I hope that, if you’ll allow …

Chicken Pepperoncini for Bloggeraid

Friday, March 20, 200927 Comments

About six months ago, a very industrious and passionate trio of bloggers organized an international consortium of even more bloggers and Bloggeraid was born. According to founders, Ivy from Kopiaste, Val from More Than Burnt Toast and Giz of Equal Opportunity Kitchen, Bloggeraid is “a growing group …

TWD: French Yogurt Cake and an Irish Blessing

Tuesday, March 17, 200949 Comments

Well, here we are on St. Patrick’s Day and I’m posting about a French Yogurt Cake. Funny, huh? But today is TWD day, and this week’s recipe is Dorie’s French Yogurt Cake with Marmalade Glaze. I’m not complaining, though, because I liked Dorie’s cake way …

Flavor of the Month: POM Wonderful Pomegranate Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream

Monday, March 16, 200946 Comments

Okay, so I know that I missed doing a Flavor of the Month entry last month. Unfortunately, I was still stuck in that damn ankle cast at the time and I couldn’t really get around yet, so I had to skip it. Thank goodness the ankle has healed …

St. Paddy’s Day Dinner Revisited: Glazed Corned Beef, Sauteed Cabbage and Colcannon

Friday, March 13, 200954 Comments

Whether you just stepped off a boat from Dublin or don’t have an ounce or Irish blood in you, you’ll most likely be doing some kind of celebrating when St. Patrick’s Day rolls around next week. I’m not much into the whole green beer thing, but I must confess …

TWD: Lemon Cup Custard

Tuesday, March 10, 200946 Comments

This week’s TWD recipe seems to have caused a lot of consternation among my baking colleagues. Many of them lamented that Dorie’s Lemon Cup Custard was just too “eggy”. I kind of don’t get that, because this recipe is for an egg custard, which by its …

kiss the cook!

Hello and welcome to SGCC! I’m Susan, a professional writer, food columnist, recipe developer, wife, mother, daughter and sister, who used to be a lawyer in a previous life. My love of food comes from a long line of wonderful and creative Italian home cooks who didn’t always have a lot, but knew how to make a lot out of what they had. I hope that you enjoy yourself while you’re here, and visit often! read more >>

Just Browsing?
55 Knives
follow me!

    Follow Me on Pinterest

    Friday Food Lust

    Fine Cooking